Tuesday, October 25, 2016

He who wears the shoe, knows where it pinches (An excerpt from the soon-to-be-published book "Green Musings", by Paul Sawa)

Undoubtedly, the Nigerian people possess everything essential for successful nation building. We have substantiated our worth, having demonstrated our capacity for excellence in almost every field of human endeavour across the globe. We have contributed directly and indirectly to the development of the most enviable economies and stable societies all over the world and yet we, somehow, fluff every prospect to work the same magic at home.

The unfortunate truth is that there is a limit to what government can do directly in these areas of training, reorientation, re-positioning and empowerment of youth through direct employment. The statistics are indeed frightening. Over 50% of Nigerian youth are unemployed. Only a fraction of these are graduates. Only a fraction of the graduates are employable. And on top of these disturbing statistics, the number of people directly employed by the Nigerian government, between 5% - 7% of the economically active population, is a drop in the ocean when compared to those employed by the private sector.

So why not empower the private sector, particularly the micro, small and medium scale enterprises through favourable legislation which translates into policies that protect and encourage economic growth? How about single digit interest rates and tax rebates/holidays? How about better government patronage of local firms since, in Nigeria, government is the biggest client?

The ripple effects need not be imagined. The larger and stronger an enterprise is encouraged to be, the wider its sphere of influence, the greater the number of ancillary services and, ultimately, the greater its number of employees and beneficiaries.  It’s so purely rational you could just as easily miss it. When businesses are encouraged to do well, workers are better paid and will have more money. More money for workers, more purchasing power; this means businesses will have more customers. Increased quantity and quality of customers results in business growth, and as businesses grow, they hire more workers.

The frustration for many small and micro businesses in Nigeria stems from the fact that, routinely, they are treated rather poorly. Banks are generally intolerant of them. Their growth is severely hampered by too many inconsistencies in government policies and programs. Why, I wonder, have erstwhile job creation and youth empowerment programs initiated by successive governments comprehensively failed, without exception? Yes, of course, we know corruption plays a key role, in fact, a gigantic role; but what about the other factors?

How on earth do you expect a group of persons with no personal experience or track record in a particular industry to make an informed decision concerning whom to empower, how to empower and where to empower? The banks in Nigeria have consistently gotten it wrong. Granted there are the few exceptions of a handful of successes, but these are more attributable to the creativity and diligence of the entrepreneur than to the quality of judgement of the banks. Unfortunately, the prevailing situation presents a somewhat unattractive spectacle.

In the horticultural industry in Nigeria, I have developed a respectable reputation as an efficiently creative problem solver and an effective project director. I am the Grand Patron to the Association of Flower Nursery and Landscape Practitioners, Abuja (AFNALPA), currently the largest umbrella group in the horticultural industry in the Federal Capital City. Although I own a nursery and propagate plants, I must admit that plant propagation is not my passion. I am more inclined to the areas of creativity and design and project management, areas that some of the best plant propagators and nursery owners that I know are severely limited in. We each know and appreciate each other’s strengths and weaknesses, and operate strictly within the various latitudes of our comparative advantages. An outsider, with no inside knowledge of the industry, would be easily outclassed by any one of us. Even if they were to come in armed with lots of capital, it would certainly be lost, sooner than later. We witnessed a lot of that with the YOUWIN youth empowerment scheme. We have been seeing quite a lot of it for decades.

Why, again, is it that small businesses are considered “fair game” by authorities and consequently overtaxed and grossly over-regulated? Transparency International describes petty corruption as the “everyday abuse of entrusted power by low and mid-level public officials in their interactions with ordinary citizens, who often are trying to access basic goods or services in places like hospitals, schools, police departments and other agencies.” What is it that creates and foments the us versus them mentality between the public officer and the private business owner? Is it not ironic that the same government that preaches job creation permits conditions which hamper the progress of Nigeria’s most prolific job creators – the micro and small businesses?  Purely on a whim, with the cursory stroke of a pen, the god-like public officer in Nigeria can attempt to effectively terminate a business dream which took decades of time, creativity, effort and capital to develop, abruptly consigning employer and employee to the annals of corporate history.

Mercifully, for every irascible, exploitative public officer that has accosted me with a discourteous, “Any problem?” or a brazen, “Oga, you must shake body o,” I have also encountered the genial, helpful and sincere alternative, who asks politely, “How can I help you, Sir?” These exceptionally responsive public servants appear as bursts of sunshine on otherwise dreary days. They treat others with the degree of dignity and respect that they expect for themselves.

For a true renaissance in Nigeria, we must comprehensively reexamine and reorient our values. We are a people of rich culture. We must reinforce some of those shared excellent cultural values, while establishing new ones. We must individually and collectively resolve, at this point, to substitute vision for purposelessness, synergism for dissonance, dependability for inconsistency, temperance for superfluity. Then, only then, can we begin to dream of reestablishing light and order in the place of this present darkness and chaos.

Saturday, July 30, 2016

Bittersweet


I distinctly remember the frustrations I felt between 2005 and 2008 every time I went to pay our modest electricity consumption bill and yet was still faced with the threat of very ill-mannered PHCN officials who insisted they would cut our power supply unless we offset the “accumulated bill.” This “accumulated bill” of over N300, 000.00 had been left unpaid by the previous occupant of the house my family had just moved into. On the other hand, we had left a clean bill where we moved out.

As is my custom, I wrote letters to all the necessary “ogas at the top,” detailing the meter reading and attaching relevant documents. I particularly let them know how, before moving, we had ensured that our electricity bills were paid in full, leaving the subsequent occupants with no liability, and hence, it was distinctly unfair that we had to bear the brunt of a previous occupant’s inattention. I personally went to the Head Office to follow up. My friend and schoolmate from UniMaid, Ibrahim Rufai, was on hand to point me in the right direction. Everywhere I went, the response was the same - it was the residence that had been billed, and not the occupant. Therefore, if I intended to seek any form of redress, it was my duty to locate the previous occupant and sort things out with him. This proved impracticable, however, as we had already received the sad news of his passing.

You can, therefore, imagine how bamboozled I felt when, with a thousand and one other pending payments, I grudgingly paid the full amount, for the sake of peace … our peace of mind! Today, when I factor in inflation to that figure (2008), I can’t help but wince.     

Well, that was then. Ever since the prepaid meters were installed, things have been relatively smoother. No need to sucker up to any unscrupulous PHCN technicians who clearly revel in the illegitimate “power” they wield over people whom they actually ought to be looking up to. No fear and trepidation whenever a PHCN truck pulls up at your street. So does this story end “happily ever after?” This is Nigeria and the story is far from over. Read on…


On March 14 there was a power surge so awful that it blew out a fridge and freezer (I had to replace the two compressors). Although I had just paid and installed over N20, 000.00 worth of electricity units two days earlier (being self-employed means I can't rely on a salary and, hence, cannot make monthly payments), the meter unit began to display an error message.

In a flash I was at the nearest AEDC office. A technician followed me home, confirmed that the meter was bad, and advised me to see his oga. I did, and was pleasantly surprised at his general demeanour. The SA Marketing - Apo Business Unit, Abuja Electricity Distribution Company was frank about the fact that I would not receive my new meter immediately. He, however, assured me that I need not worry about power since I would be given a direct connection and billed by estimate, until the new meter is installed. Needless to say, the last bit disturbed me, but I chose to keep faith and give him the benefit of the doubt.  

True to form, I had already written my letter and just needed a specific addressee, which I now had. I was advised to make a payment by bank draft of N49, 311.00 to AEDC and attach same to my letter of complaint. I also attached a copy of the slip indicating my March 12 payment of N20, 000.00.

During the ensuing three months, I waited with baited breath to see if I would be harassed, in any way, concerning electricity payments. I wasn’t. In fact, when I was away in Jos with my wife for my son’s treatment, I sent one of my workers to pay a little amount so that my mother wouldn’t suffer embarrassment of any kind from overzealous inspectors or technicians in my absence. Fellow Nigerians, lo and behold, he was told that the payment was not necessary!!!


On the 25th of July, 2016 I received a phone call from an AEDC technician, asking me to come to the office and sign for the new meter. I complied, and he followed me home and did the installation. I was overjoyed to see that the casing was made in Nigeria – from Momas Electricity Meters Manufacturing Company in Ogun State.

As is evident in my bittersweet account, a lot is just not right in Naija (as if anyone needed any further proof!). I am not blind to that. For example

1.       Why should I have to pay for a meter that went bad as the direct result of a power surge?
2.       Why shouldn’t I be reimbursed for expenditures as the result of damage caused to my fridge and freezer as the direct result of a power surge? No liability for them, only privilege?
3.       And although the meter came eventually … why did it take four months!?

Although I am vociferous and unrelenting in my criticism, when and where necessary, I am also just as willing to commend positive effort, no matter how minimal, whenever and wherever I see it. I appreciate some of the challenges faced by our utility service providers. Sometimes if you have not worn that shoe, you may not fully understand the pinch.

The positives in my story should actually be more of the rule than the exception. When and how are we going to get there? A step at a time, I guess. The journey of a thousand miles begins with one step, no matter how tentative. If you can’t relate with Confucius, maybe you should ask “Oga at the Top” Fashola …

Friday, July 15, 2016

The Tragedy of Misorientation and Warped Values


In May, 2011, the then head of the IMF, Dominique Strauss-Kahn, was accused of sexually assaulting and attempting to rape a chambermaid at a New York hotel. The maid, a 32-year-old immigrant from Guinea, said that Strauss-Kahn attacked her in his room while she was cleaning.

In a written statement, Strauss-Kahn announced that he’d devote all his energy to fighting sexual assault charges against him. “It is with infinite sadness that I feel compelled today to present to the executive board my resignation from my post of managing director of the IMF," his letter to International Monetary Fund reads. "I want to protect this institution which I have served with honor and devotion and especially – especially – I want to devote all my strength, all my time and all my energy to proving my innocence," he said.


On June 9, 2016, the US Ambassador to Nigeria, James Entwistle, petitioned the Speaker of the House of Representatives, Hon. Yakubu Dogara, alleging that actions of three Nigerian lawmakers at the International Visitor Leadership Programme in Cleveland, Ohio, USA, from 7th to 13th April, 2016, brought disrepute to the parliament by soliciting for sex from prostitutes and grabbing a hotel housekeeper in a bid to rape.


Consider the dynamics in each of these two scenarios. In the first instance, a powerful global figure who commanded the respect of world leaders was destroyed by the accusation of a chambermaid on immigrant status. In our second instance, a lowly housekeeper and parking lot attendant received the attention and protection of a consulate, which has refused to back down and/or be intimidated by what they clearly regard as puerile threats from the accused lawmakers in the face of glaring evidence they purport to have. In both of these cases, existing societal values ensured that the endangered were protected while the delinquent were sanctioned.

The global historical political landscape is littered with carcasses of dashed hopes and ruins of veritably promising political careers which succumbed to the ravenous fiend that takes no prisoners – the monster of sexual scandal. Yet in Nigeria, that monster appears to have been tamed by a larger, fiercer one - the hydra-headed dragon of corruption. Too frequently when we speak of corruption, we think only of financial impropriety or fiscal irresponsibility. The corruption I speak of here, however, is the perversion of truth, the veering of a society away from the highway of sound moral and socio-cultural values to a purposeless wandering in the dark, back alleys of primal predispositions where vice is exalted over virtue, and might takes precedence over right.

The actions, or inactions, of the Nigerian Senate over the recent altercation between Senators Remi Tinubu and Dino Melaye will have a significant influence on whether Nigerians, as a people, will henceforward bother to accord them any modicum of respect. There is a civil code which is considered an irreducible minimum and, hence, must remain sacrosanct. This code protects our mothers, wives and daughters from direct conflict, or the threat of it. Somebody in the Senate clearly didn’t get that memo! Real men will comfortably challenge other men and, in cultured society today, the tool of preference is no longer bulging biceps, but clever concepts unless, of course, you're competing for a bodybuilding trophy. On the contrary, however, wussies prefer to bully women using the singular edge that they perceive they have over them … testosterone-driven terrorization.


For me, it’s pretty simple. When a serving Senator and wife to the ruling party’s strongman is threatened with rape on the floor of the once-hallowed chambers by a man who boasts that he will, one day, be President of Nigeria, and nothing comes of it … evidently, the gloves are officially off! This intra-senatorial handshake has extended beyond the elbow and the punches are landing far below the waist. It is indicative of what will eventually follow. A Senate which cannot (or will not) defend one of its own, most certainly cannot (and will not) defend the people it purports to represent. This is NOT the Nigeria we want!


The kidnapping of the Chibok girls was a rape on our collective sensibilities. But then again, we all conceded that Abubakar Shekau and his ilk were insane (the state of mind of his behind-the-scenes handlers is another matter altogether!).


The actions of the Honourable Speaker of the House of Representatives, Hon. Yakubu Dogara, in swiftly ordering a probe into the alleged sexual impropriety involving three members was highly commendable, indicating a sincere desire to uphold sanity. While insisting that the accused trio deserved a fair hearing, the decision of the ethics and privileges and foreign affairs committees was to conduct a public hearing, insisting that "we are not going to shield anyone."


So maybe I’m just a tad bit early. Let’s give the Nigerian Senate the benefit of the doubt. Maybe someone’s preparing an official statement. Maybe someone’s about to get the boot. Maybe they’ll opt for sanity. Let’s give it till Monday…



Scourge of Decadence

Fool will hie with glee, where angel scarce would tread.
Jack and knave would fain assail the stooped baronial head.
Golden strands will shimmer, of webs spun in the night,
Deluding prince, and queen, and king; defining wrong as right.

How are the mighty fallen, as nobles are defamed.
Currish rascals boldly bray, while sage recoils in shame.
Raptor pecks with chickens, mules graze with unicorn,
Philosopher and scholar, ruled by boor, are guyed to scorn.

Paul Sawa